Friday, 6 June 2014

The Significator Destroy The House(Karaka bava nasaya)



The word Karaka means a 'significator' or a planet which represents particular things of human life such as marriage or children or job etc. For ex: Venus is karaka for marriage.Bhava means house 
and Nashya means destroyer.
In order to understand the implications of this concept, I researched alot. During my research, this concept has almost failed in some particular cases. I would like to share few instances. I studied a person’s chart.  I saw Jupiter in 5th house and found the person blessed with good children. However, for Venus in 7th house, this concept is applicable in few cases.
For more comprehensive view,  read below my detailed research report on this principle:
1.  Sun and 10th house, both are karaka for job. So, according to this rule if sun is placed in 10th house then the native won’t enjoy good professional life. But it’s not true! The reason is according to Shad bala concept, sun gets digbala (directional strength) when it’s placed in 10th house. It means sun is very powerful when it’s placed in 10th house. The native will enjoy respective career life. So this rule failed here.
2. Jupiter is the karaka of the 2nd, 5th, 10th and the 11th house. So when Jupiter is placed in any of these houses, then according to this rule, it will destroy the house related matters. For instance if Jupiter is placed in 2nd house then it will spoil the wealth, family matters of an individual. But, according to me, this is untrue. In my experience, I have seen lot of people who are born with Jupiter in 2nd house, enjoying good wealth and family. Wherever Jupiter is placed, it will bring positive strength to that house expect some cases.
3. Mars is the karaka of the 3rd and the 6th house. So when Mars is placed in 3rd house, it will destroy your siblings, courage etc because 3rd house represents siblings and courage. But, I have come across the people whose 3rd house has Mars but they still have good relationships and are brave.
4. Venus and 7th house both are karaka for marriage. So when Venus is placed in 7th house, it must give bad results in married life. For very few cases but not all, this rule works. To prove my point, I would like to share one of my case studies.  I came across a boy born in cancer ascendant with Venus in 7th house. This boy suffered in his marriage life and got divorced. The reason was that Venus was destroying 7th house related things as per the principle of "Karako Bhavo Nashaya".
I would like to conclude that "Karako Bhavo Nashaya" does not work for all cases such as Jupiter in 5th house will not spoil the 5th bava. I have experienced this in many cases. With the exception of few cases such as Venus in 7th house, this rule is not applicable for most of the cases.

16 comments:

  1. Great Astrologer
    from Amina SHeikh

    ReplyDelete
  2. sir my karka for profession is venus .. my lagna is leo .. and venus is placed in libra rashi 3rd house from lagna .. what does it indicates

    rahil khan

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Generally it indicates profession in communication such as teaching etc. but we need to see ur d10 chart deeply to conclude which career u going to enjoy.
      Regards
      Ram

      Delete
  3. sir my karaka for marriage is saturn, placed 12th from aquarius sign, placed 6th from lagna .. my lagna is leo and rashi is aquarius ?? does that indicate bad marriage life or bad life partner or sad relationship ????????????

    ReplyDelete
  4. nope, ur saturn is placed in own sign , depeneds upon d9 chart we can tell exactly

    ReplyDelete
  5. i have seen instances where it destroys a single significance of that house.e.g sun in 10th, career is great ,but the relationship with the father is not the best.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Nope, i seen many cases where sun placed in 10th/9th house and the individual relationship with father is good and in ur study case mostly the individual d12chart(chart to study parents) have some negativity or 10th or 9th house condition is not good

      regards

      Delete
  6. hi.. i like your post.. thank you.. many astrologers are using this principle to scare off people.. i believe exceptions are there.. one of my friend has jupiter in 5th cancer with moon.. astrologer said 5th jupiter is NISHFALA, meaning it wont produce any fruits..i have jupiter in 11th with ketu, makara lagna... do u think is it also a case of exception??

    warm regards

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. ur jup is well placed in 11th house it will blesses ur 5th 3rd by its aspects , no worries just ignore this karaka bavanasaya concept for jup in ur case and generally jup blesses where its sits
      regards

      Delete
  7. hi.. i like your post.. thank you.. many astrologers are using this principle to scare off people.. i believe exceptions are there.. one of my friend has jupiter in 5th cancer with moon.. astrologer said 5th jupiter is NISHFALA, meaning it wont produce any fruits..i have jupiter in 11th with ketu, makara lagna... do u think is it also a case of exception??

    warm regards

    ReplyDelete
  8. Sir, I am an Aries ascendant. My Saturn is placed in the 8th house (Scorpio) in Anuradha Nakshatra with Rahu (Jyeshta Nakshatra). Jupiter is in 5th house (Magha) and Venus (Ashwini) in Lagna . What will be the effect of 8th House?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. saturn in 8th house is ok but where is 8th lord(mars) placed that is important, jup in 5th house is quite good

      Delete
  9. Hello sir.7th n 10th lord mercury with 9th lord sun and 12th lord mars where mars retrograde,moon in lagna with empty 7th house,what about my married life,started learning the sub recently so really confused,jup also retro n exalted in 8th house,pl guide.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Dear, Guruji, In my case Pisces Ascendent

    I have Mars in 3rd House Relationship with my brother is hard

    I have Guru in 5th House With Ketu my studies not Satisfactory

    11th house Saturn i see no luck

    10th house sun no emotional connection with father

    ReplyDelete